History

The Outlaw Years
The Plummer Gang

 

 

 

 

Click below on a subject in "Outlaws and Crime".

Click here to return to the main History page


   T
he Plummer Gang is probably the most notorious band of outlaws to ever plague Garfield County.  It seems incredible that such a band of thieves and cut-throats could continue their depredations so long without running afoul of the law.  However, when considered that in those early days there was no organized government, no courts and no peace officers, it is understandable that such an organization might continue its criminal exploits for a long period without arrest and punishment. 

   There were organized bands of outlaws who plundered the merchants in towns, pack trains and stages on the road, and miners moving to and from their camps.  The members had passwords and they tied their neckties with a special knot by which they would disclose their identity to each other.  They had regular routes along which they operated and stations where members of the gang were located.  They had members in every camp and town engaged in various occupations.  When organized government was established, leaders often succeeded in being elected sheriff, marshal, chief of police, etc.  They knew when every pack train started, the goods it carried, and the amount of gold dust it brought back.  They watched every stranger and learned his business; they took note of every good horse; they knew of the departure of every stage, the number of passengers and the probable gold it carried.  The loan traveler was robbed of his horse by a forged bill of sale.

      The most noted of these gang leaders was Henry Plummer.  His band maintained a hide-out or "shebang" as it was called on the Pataha about six miles east of the site of Pomeroy, at the point where the Nez Perce trail left the valley on the east ward course over the Alpowa Ridge.  There was a log house at this place during the early sixties (1860's), which was used as the gang's hideout.

     A few facts about the leader of this band may be of interest.  Henry Plummer appears to have come from a good family.  He was rather handsome, with an attractive personality, he was well dressed and upon arriving in a community, made a good impression.

     Plummer came to Lewiston, Id. (30 miles east of Pomeroy) in 1861.  He lived as a respectable citizen, a quiet and law-abiding man with a woman who posed and was accepted as his wife.  Here he established leadership of a band of outlaws, organized and managed in a totally unbelievable manner.

    For a time in his wild career of crime, Plummer "went straight", influenced no doubt, by his marriage to a respectable young woman.  When one of his pals fell in love with his wife, however, threatening Plummer's peace of mind with the danger of exposure, Plummer could only settle the impending menace to his security by resorting to the well-gained criminal tendencies from his past.

    He organized a bigger and more efficient gang than before, still posing as the honest and efficient of the law.  But when two members of the gang were arrested, for some reason they betrayed Plummer, telling the vigilantly committee all.  Plummer was arrested, as well as part of his crowd, and brought to the very scaffold he had himself erected.  Now it was his turn to beg and plead for his life, which he did more eloquently and movingly than any of the unfortunate men he had slain in cold blood.

     His cries fell on deaf ears.  Struggling, crying hysterically, trying to break free, he was brought and placed under the gallows.  Then resigned to his fate, he tore off his necktie, the emblem of his organization, and threw it to a young man who had boarded with.  "Keep that to remember me by!"

     He turned to the vigilantes who were placing the noose around his neck.  "Now, men, as a last favor let me beg you to give me a good drop.

     That was the one request they could grant, and they carried out the final wish of this notorious outlaw to the last, grim letter.