History

Cattle Rustl'n

In Garfield County

 

 

Click below on a subject in "Outlaws and Crime".

Click  here to return to the main History page

 

 

     Cattle rustling and horse stealing were common offenses in Garfield County in the early nineties (1890's), as well as in other parts of Eastern Washington.  The vigilante days were on the wane at that time, and while many offenders were detected and punished, a goodly number were never apprehended.

     A bold gang of rustlers was organized, apparently in Dayton, in the early nineties and operated successfully for a considerable time, though beef steers were selling for ten to fifteen dollars per head.  One member of the gang, George Young, established a slaughter house on the Patit Creek above Dayton, and operated a market in Dayton.  Cattle were stolen by other members of the gang in Garfield, Columbia, and Asotin Counties, and many of them were taken to Young's slaughterhouse, where they were butchered, their hides, bearing the brands of the rightful owners buried, and their meat sold at Young's shop.  Young was finally caught, convicted and served a term of time at the penitentiary.  He failed to implicate any of his associates.

     In the summer of 1894, Billie Lloyd, Bud Pettijon, Chan Taylor and John Long made arrangements to deliver a car-load (rail car) of cattle to a ranch on the Tucanon.  Lloyd, Pettijon, and Taylor were seen driving 30 head of cattle belonging to an Asotin rancher toward the Tucannon.  The following is the account of Deputy Allen of Columbia County describing the capture and arrest of these men, as it appeared in the Columbia Chronicle:

In company with the sheriff of Garfield County, two deputies, and four citizens, we went to a place at the head of the Alpowa, as we expected the gang to come along that evening.  They did not appear, but last evening just as we had finished supper Lloyd and Pettijon came riding along.  Knowing Lloyd well, I called him by name, told him to throw up his hands and consider himself under arrest.  He pulled his gun, dropped over on the other side of his horse and commenced shooting.  We fired three shots at his horse, and he started to run, firing at me continuously.  Pettijon also dismounted and started to run, firing at the other officers.  Twice Lloyd came near hitting me, shooting once under my left arm, and once just to the right-making this hole."

Here Allen pointed to two holes in his left pantaloon leg, just below the knee.  One bullet made both holes and cut the underclothing, but did not touch the flesh.  Allen continued:

"After a 200 yard chase, Lloyd and Pettijon surrendered.  Lloyd had two flesh wounds, below and above the left knee.  Pettijon was shot twice with a Winchester in the left thigh.  The wound is a bad one and the leg will probably have to be amputated.  None of the officers were hit.  We then went on down the canyon several miles and captured Chan Taylor, another of the gang who was driving the cattle.  I rode alongside of him and shoved a pistol under his nose.  He saw there was no chance to escape and threw up his hands.  We took the prisoners to Pomeroy, where they could receive medical attention.  In addition to the 30 cattle from Asotin, they had stolen another 30 head which they were driving."

     Judge M.F. Gose of Pomeroy was employed to conduct the prosecution of the rustlers.  Lloyd was tried and convicted at Asotin in April of 1895 and was sentenced to serve three years in the penitentiary.  Chan Taylor entered a plea of guilty at the same term of court and was given the same sentence.  Pettijon was tried at the same term and, strange as it may seem, was acquitted.  Since he was crippled for life by his wounds, from which he nearly died and had served several months in jail, perhaps the jury concluded he had been sufficiently punished.